Former Karnataka Minister and BJP leader Murugesh Nirani has challenged Food and Civil Supplies Minister Rizwan Arshad’s claims that petrol sold at fuel outlets in the state contains ethanol above the prescribed 20% blending level, calling for fresh inspections and testing under a transparent procedure involving government officials, laboratory scientists and oil marketing companies.
Speaking at a press conference in Mysuru on 18 November, Nirani said senior officials, including Deputy Commissioners, representatives of the Food and Civil Supplies Department, laboratory scientists and oil marketing companies, should be involved when fuel samples are collected from retail outlets.
His remarks add to the ongoing dispute between the Karnataka government and oil marketing companies over the reported ethanol content in petrol samples.
Nirani calls for joint sampling and independent verification
Nirani disputed the testing process cited by Arshad and called for a committee comprising designated government officials and oil company representatives to conduct fresh inspections at fuel outlets.
He said action could be taken against oil marketing companies if excess ethanol content was established through inspections conducted under the proposed procedure.
Nirani also rejected the possibility of excessive ethanol blending taking place at the retail outlet level. His position contrasts with Arshad’s earlier allegations that samples collected across Karnataka had shown ethanol levels above the prescribed limit.
Karnataka minister cites tests reporting ethanol levels above 20%
Arshad has alleged that petrol samples collected in the state contained ethanol concentrations exceeding the 20% blending level. He previously said that 14 samples tested by independent laboratories accredited by the National Accreditation Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories (NABL) showed ethanol content ranging from 13.5% to 31.2%, with 11 samples reportedly exceeding 20%.
The minister has also questioned the information provided by oil marketing companies and called for greater transparency in fuel-quality testing and disclosure of ethanol content.
The state government’s allegations have been disputed by the oil marketing companies. Indian Oil Corporation, Bharat Petroleum Corporation and Hindustan Petroleum Corporation have maintained that E20 petrol supplied by them conforms to the applicable Bureau of Indian Standards specification, IS 17021.
The companies have also raised concerns about the sampling and testing procedures used in the state government’s exercise. In a separate set of tests, the companies said 56 samples tested in Karnataka recorded ethanol content between 19% and 20%, with an average of 19.30%.
The two sets of reported results relate to different samples and testing exercises. Their contrasting findings underline the need to establish the sampling methods, laboratory procedures and applicable standards before drawing conclusions about fuel quality across the state.
Dispute puts focus on ethanol-blending compliance
India’s ethanol blending programme aims to reduce dependence on imported crude oil and support domestic agricultural feedstock supply chains. The prescribed blending level and compliance with fuel-quality standards remain central to the programme’s implementation.
The Karnataka dispute has brought attention to how ethanol content is measured, how fuel samples are collected and tested, and how results are communicated to regulators and consumers.
Nirani has called for fresh testing with participation from relevant stakeholders. The outcome of any further joint inspection or independently verified testing could help clarify the competing claims about ethanol content in petrol sold in the state.





